On the supercharged 4-tec... you need 91. They CAN de-tune themselves if you put in 87. BUT... if the knock sensor is going bad... and the MPEM doesn't lower the timing... you can burn a piston.
I am confused by your comment. My 2012 SC 255 C180 has a sticker by the gas cap that specifically states to use 87 octane gas. I understand that you can get (slightly) better performance by using 91 octane, but is it really a risk to use 87?
What he means is that if you're running 87 in your SC motor you're relying on your knock sensor to detect detonation and retard timing to prevent said detonation. If a knock sensor was to fail, which they can, you're very likely to cause catastrophic damage to your engine in the form of shattered pistons. Been there done that (automotive application but the cause and effect were the same). In any boosted motor (SC or Turbo) you should be running premium. I'm willing to bet that in your owner's manual it says somewhere that you CAN run 87 but premium is recommended. That what my manual for my 08 says. And yes I do have the same sticker by the gas cap that you make a mention if. If you invest so much of your hard earned money into your boat why risk ruining it over a few pennies per gallon?