I can't seem to find any pictures on the internet that look like the PTO on my 96 XP. I'm wondering if the part is aftermarket? And if it is, should I replace it with a stock part since I'm biased towards reliability vs speed.
There are tons of good used ones out there in the 20-25 dollar shipped range so don't pay too much. Your old one is worth at least that to somebody willing to give up a little reliability for a performance increase.