I tried the hand brush first and found that at $4-5 a pop it was going to get expensive doing a pint at a time, which is all you can do mixing and applying before it starts to gel up. You've only have about 10 minutes once you mix in the catalyst. I went with the small 4 inch rollers, about $10 for a pack of 6, and disposable plastic trays for about $1 a pop. Finally got the agitating, measuring and mixing down. I was unsuccessful at first, it was going on too thin (sanding through afterward) even when I switched and rolled a coat over it. Back to square one again, I rolled it on thick as I could with about 3 coats and the results improved on the sanding/finishing stage. Sanding and finishing with 120 is a little too aggressive, leaves deeper scratches that run the risk of sanding through trying to remove. So I started wet sanding with 320 and 400, then moved to the finer grits. I went through almost 2 gallons of black, but safe to say I wasted almost a gallon before I starting getting things right. Go on thick, several coats, not thin, which seems to be difficult with brushable gelcoat. The brushable is rougher because of brush marks left behind when it drys compared to spraying, so it requires deeper sanding. I highly recommend to only do a pint at a time, you don't have a lot of time to mix and apply much more per setting.
One more thing, life got easier getting into the final sanding once I picked up a 2 inch air sander from Habor Freight. I'm on top side about to apply the white gelcoat, waiting on a warmer day in the 70's. I'm happy with the results on the bottom side, but lots of work, I'll post some pics soon.