Could be an infinite number of things, lets try to narrow it down. As racerxxx says, a video will help with the tick noise. Do you know where the tick is coming from? (front, top , rear of engine, pump, etc...)
Edit:
I wonder if you spin it by hand you will still hear or feel it?
Any work done on it recently?
your town is in Ontario or Wisconsin...both a trek from Erie. I guess your on a trip right now.